Could the house of cards come tumbling down?
In just one week, three different “substantive and significant” actions have come from New York’s Office of Renewable Energy Siting (ORES), which has forced solar and wind industrial complexes on 50 different Upstate New York towns and villages.
The battle felt bleak in the beginning. I knew I had my work cut out for me, peeling away layers of a bureaucratic body that’s continued to swell in size for the last three decades. I’d be lying if I didn’t say I felt delusional at times, thinking I could make a dent at all here.
But I’ve learned in my life that consistency, always, every single time, pays off. And from consistency comes synergy.
One year after attending the Fort Edward Solar hearing, there are lawsuits being filed against ORES all over the state, especially from Montgomery County and my nonprofit, American Land Rescue Fund. New Yorkers are standing up and taking photos of these fraudulent solar companies, posting damning videos on the Internet to shed light on their destructive construction practices. The press can no longer ignore what’s happening across the Empire State, begrudgingly acknowledging that we have some unlikely “power players” in the fight against irresponsible renewable energy sprawl.
It’s converging at the perfect time, causing ORES to admit fault it never intended to disclose to the public one year ago. And in the middle of it all, New York’s other agencies, like the Department of Public Service (DPS) and the Department of Environmental Conservation (DEC), are admitting, out in the open, that they, too, are tired of the bureaucratic gangsters at ORES steamrolling their agencies.
Here’s what this momentum produced this week:
DPS judges recommend the Shepherd’s Run Solar permit be denied
In a move that’s shocked even the attorneys that have been on the ORES scene since 2021, the two Administrative Law Judges (ALJs) assigned to Shepherd’s Run Solar in Copake, New York, issued a 75-page recommended decision this week that the permit be denied to Hecate Energy.
The ORES Executive Director, Jason Zehr, whose family has ties to logging operations and DEC logging contracts in our state, can still override this recommended decision. But it’s unprecedented for DPS judges to go against a solar developer and recommend that a permit be outright denied. It’s never happened since ORES was created sneakily inside of a budget bill.
Regardless of Zehr’s decision, the 75-page recommended decision equips every Upstate New York town with information, clues, and a playbook on how they, too, can save their land from solar industrial complexes.
I attended the Shepherd’s Run Solar adjudicatory hearing in Copake last month, where the developer was caught lying so many times under oath that I lost count. It was clear the ALJs had called the hearing to order so the public could see, finally, the flawed ORES process in the light. This marks a shocking and sudden departure from the DPS as it relates to ORES, with the DEC present that day as well to make it known that they, too, are frustrated by the ORES process.
ORES admits they wronged Montgomery County by pulling the protective order
Back in the spring, Montgomery County attorney Meghan Manion filed for a protective order to review the pre-application materials for Cow Bell Solar, sited for Florida, New York. ORES agreed, at first, to grant the protective order so the county could look at important information as it relates to the buildout of industrial solar complexes. The developer, however, quickly asked ORES to rescind the protective order on the grounds of “trade secrets.” ORES immediately sided with the developer and went back on granting the county access to the documents.
The Montgomery County Legislature gave Manion permission to bring forth a lawsuit over this decision last month. To no one’s surprise, upon hearing about an incoming lawsuit, ORES suddenly issued a notice that they would “re-review” the July 20th decision.
Manion was quoted this week in the Daily Gazette saying:
“I think the fact that ORES is taking this under their own review, prior to having this addressed in Supreme Court, is a sign that there are serious concerns about the decision-making process that was made in determining that Montgomery County was not allowed access to unredacted documents.”
Granting counties and towns the right to review solar materials in the pre-application phase would be another unprecedented win for our small towns that have been removed from the energy siting process in New York State (purposely). Our pushback was deemed “cumbersome” to those in Albany.
Manion went on to conclude:
“Government is based on the pillar of open access to documents and to deny a municipality documents in an active proceeding that directly involves that municipality goes against all of the tenets of law that we follow in New York State.”
ORES has admitted they wronged Montgomery County and its request to see the Cow Bell Solar documents by re-reviewing a decision they made haphazardly to please, as always, the foreign renewable energy developers.
Flat Creek Solar permit relinquishment is officially accepted by ORES
After Pattern Energy Group, represented by Young/Sommer, filed to relinquish the Flat Creek Solar final permit last month, ORES responded that they did not accept the relinquishment on the grounds that it was not filed correctly.
We all held our breath the last two weeks, wondering if Young/Sommer would be able to process the relinquishment correctly so we could move on from a solar complex that would have completely destroyed the Amish of Canajoharie, New York.
ORES finally verified concurrence with the relinquishment of the siting permit this week. Flat Creek Solar is officially dead.
This is the first ORES solar complex to receive a final permit, and proceed with relinquishing it.
The tides are turning
All of these wins this week give the people, towns, and nonprofits (and our amazing attorneys) ammunition and insight into how we can continue to keep the pressure on the unreachable bureaucrats at ORES.
There is a lot more to come, so stick around.
FURTHER READING
New York’s ORES solar complexes are being used to fund foreign pension plans
Last week, the unthinkable happened: a notice was filed on the Department of Public Service docket for Flat Creek Solar announcing the final siting permit had been relinquished by the developer. I covered why the permit was relinquished here.
The Flat Creek Solar ORES permit has officially been relinquished: here’s why.
Covering the Office of Renewable Energy Siting (ORES) in New York State has been a depressing pursuit for the last 12 months. There is hardly ever any good news that spills out of this shadow bureaucratic agency, which was given the legal power to supersede our home rule, local zoning laws, and environmental regulations.
POLITICO confirms: public pushback and social media outrage are impacting solar and wind companies
I braced myself last weekend for what I believed would be a total hit piece on me, my life, my past, and my activism in the irresponsible solar and wind sprawl space across Upstate New York. From the conversations I had with the POLITICO reporter, I knew the article was trending in a not-so-favorable direction.










Amazing what can be accomplished when consistent and relentless pressure is applied.
Keep in mind this is an election year. The regime in power will allow small victories (in the grand scheme of staying in power, a few solar projects can be sacrificed) to prevent the Citizens from seeking change. True victory can only be achieved by changing the regime that allowed ORES as well as other unconstitutional actions.
The fact DPS and DEC are speaking up is a good sign that momentum should continue